In his first week as a college player, E.J. Cumbo hit a ball into the gap and he dashed out of the box in what appeared to be a routine double. The problem was that as he hit the first base bag, his hamstring tore and he collapsed in pain. What should’ve been a joyous moment meant his freshman season was over. His team, the NY Tech Bears, were in the midst of a disappointing season in their first season as a Division-II program.
If you freeze time in that moment, think of the likelihood that Cumbo would end up eclipsing 400 collegiate hits and appear in three Division-II College World Series. The chances of that would be impossible to fathom but that is precisely what happened as Cumbo would make one stop in the southeast after playing close to his backyard for two seasons.
But first let’s turn the clock back..

The Early Days
EJ Cumbo was the first of three boys born in the Cumbo family. He was born in Queens, NY but the family moved to East Setauket in 2012 when he was in middle school. His first taste of Long Island baseball was with the 3 Village Patriots.
He recalls playing at Ripken tournament and hitting an inside-the-park homer against a team coached by former Mets reliever Roberto Hernandez, which he called one of the moments that stood out to him about his younger days as a ballplayer.
Baseball is in his blood, as his father played at St. Francis Prep and played his collegiate ball at Fairfield University.
Cumbo cited two players he tried to emulate his game after; one contemporary and one legendary – Charlie Blackmon and Mickey Mantle. Despite Mantle starring 50 years before he was even born, he stated that he chose to wear No. 7 on the diamond because of him. Blackmon also impacted his game; a left-handed hitting outfielder that played the game at 100% at all times.
In his youth, Cumbo also played football but quit at the age of 10 and played JV basketball but quit to focus on baseball.
The family moved from East Setauket to East Meadow in 2013, a decision that would have a tremendous impact on Clarke baseball as all three boys would go on to star for coach Tom Abruscato.
Most people do not know this about EJ, but he actually attended Long Island Lutheran when he was in 9th grade due to the fact that his neighbor was a minister there and he convinced the family to send him there. It was not necessarily a regret for EJ as he was able to varsity as a 9th grader, as opposed to staying at Clarke and playing on JV.
Clarke HS
After the year, EJ and his parents made the decision to go back to Clarke HS. He recalls having a meeting with Coach who was thrilled to have him back. He was no stranger to the program, as he has been hitting with the varsity team during their Sunday workouts since he was in middle school.
His earliest memory of Clarke baseball was in 2013 when he went to the Class A Long Island Championship and they lost to Bayport-Blue Point. He recalls his future mentor and 2x All-State player, Joe Fusco, crying after the game and he wanted to experience a County Championship during his high school career. Surprisingly, that never occurred despite all of Clarke’s success over the years.
It was no fault of his own, as EJ would go on to rewrite the school’s record books with a historic 3-year run in which he was named All-County three times and All-State twice. Their best seasons came during his sophomore year in which they lost to Valley Stream North and his senior season when they lost at Carey.
During that season, he batted a ridiculous .536 with 23 RBIs and 19 stolen bases. Looking at the stats alone you would assume EJ was a big kid – maybe 6’2 or 6’3. That is not the case as he is 5’5 and that is what caused him to work harder than most as he was consistently overlooked.
Despite having to overcome the obstacle that his height presented, he recalled during his college recruiting process with the Long Island Titans that he had sat in his meeting with Tom Downey who discussed his options of playing Division-I at the local schools.
He noted that Hofstra and St. John’s flat out told him he was too small to play there. He was also interested in NY Tech and Stony Brook.
Fortunately for him, Joe Fusco had transferred from Hofstra to NY Tech and he highly recommended him to the coaching staff. On a Sunday morning, head coach Bob Malvagna and assistant coach Rob Savarese came out to watch him in the gym. Just from watching him hit front toss, he was offered a scholarship two days later.
While he was technically able to achieve his goal of getting a Division-I scholarship, NY Tech announced they would be dropping down to Division-II and competing in the ECC in 2018.
NY Tech
EJ Cumbo hits a 3-R HR and NYIT leads 3-0 in the first ! https://t.co/7uTZW8o07l
— Axcess Baseball LI (@axcessbaseball) May 25, 2019
If you think it was disappointing for a group of Division-I players to be told they are now Division-II players, imagine the feeling after they missed the playoffs in 2018. As shocking as that sounds, it was a extremely poor season for NY Tech in 2018 as they won just 13 games.
Where do you go from there?
It turns out they had a trick up their sleeve in the form of a familiar name in the world of Long Island baseball and that was 14-year veteran Frank Catalanotto, who had been drafted out of Smithtown East HS by the Detroit Tigers.
As big of a surprise as this was, the obvious challenge was that Catalanotto had no experience coaching college baseball and he had inherited a very flawed roster that just won 13 games.
As we would later find out, Catalanotto had a couple aces in his deck as well; hiring a pair of experienced and well-respected coaches in Chris Rojas and Jimmy Goelz.
Cumbo admitted that while he was only somewhat familiar with Catalanotto, “It was pretty awesome to find out he was taking over. My dad was fired up. Obviously I heard of him since there’s only so many Long Islanders that played in the big leagues.”
From the jump, Catalanotto pulled no punches, telling the team in their first meeting that they were going to change things around. They immediately brought in some big-time transfers such as CF Johnny LaRocca from Monmouth and 2b Chris Campbell from Grambling State.
That wasn’t necessarily good news for Cumbo who stated “I knew I was going to have to move to right field since Johnny played center.”
Assistant coach Jimmy Goelz was brutally honest with him. Cumbo recalls talking to him one day during the fall, “He told me ‘if you keep swinging like this, you’re going to hit .230 this season.” He added that Catalanotto was sort of more reserved but being that he was a big leaguer, “when he talks, you listen.”
As far as expectations, there was none. Cumbo noted they were picked to be around the 250th best team in the country. From inside the clubhouse, though, they knew that was nonsense.
“It really started during the fall World Series. It showed us we can compete. We spent all of our time together. We went out as a team. When the season started, we went down to Myrtle Beach and smoked a team so we were 1-0 and it was like, alright, we haven’t been above .500 in two years. That was a spring board.”
Interestingly enough, Cumbo was benched during the third game of the season. He admitted his hamstring was still causing him to be a bit timid when going after the ball in the outfield and they played at a field in Myrtle Beach with a hill in right field and he didn’t hustle going after a ball. He went benched, but he didn’t allow it to snowball on him.
“I remember having a conversation with Fusco and my dad and they were like, what’s going on you’re not hitting like you should.”
The next game Cumbo went 3-for-5 with 2 HRs and he never looked back.
NY Tech went on a hot streak after that and they were able to host the ECC playoffs thanks to a 21-7 conference record. Shockingly, they lost twice to Bridgeport to (seemingly) have their dreams cut short. Their rivals LIU Post wound up winning 15-0 in the finals against Bridgeport to punch their ticket to the regionals.
But that was not the case.
Thanks to their stellar regular season, they earned the final bid in the NCAA East Regional.
“We knew we’d have a shot at a bid,” said Cumbo. “We were 37-8 or something. The wins carried weight, we showed up in the auditorium watching the selection show. We got the last bid and we all just exploded. Guys were ripping off their shirts in excitement. Next day we went back to work. We said we really shouldn’t even be here. This is our chance to make a name for ourselves.”
And make a name for themselves they did. In the NCAA East Regional, which was hosted by Adelphi University, the NY Tech bats exploded and they did not slow down. On May 18, one year after winning 13 games, they took down Wilmington for the second time of the weekend to punch their ticket to the Super Regional against Southern New Hampshire.
“We were just clicking on all cylinders,” said Cumbo. “I think me and Jake Lebel went back-to-to-back twice. With DJ Masuck on the mound, we knew even if he might give up runs he was going to keep us in the game every time.”
They had many incredible stories that year, but one of them was closer Ariel Taveras who was a walk-on and went on to to save a program single-season record of 12 games.
The next week was an even more formidable opponent in Southern New Hampshire, at their place.
“We knew all about them. But we felt like we were playing with house money – we were two wins away from the College World Series at this point. SNHU is expected to win, the had two of the top arms in the country. Everything that you think about SNHU, that’s what they were.”
And just like the previous weeks, the bats came out hot. They won 9-8 with the ultimate winning run coming on a solo shot by Kieran Dowd in the 9th inning. Cumbo noted how incredible it was for a freshman to have three hits and a clutch homer in a huge moment like that.
The next day, it wasn’t nearly as high-scoring but they didn’t need it to be. Cumbo set the tone in the first inning with a 3-run blast to jump start the offense.
Southpaw Joe Keller came on in relief and fired 4.1 shutout innings to slam the door and put an exclamation point on a Cinderella story. The Bears were headed to the Division-II College World Series.
“I was just on Cloud 9 that whole week. We were all pumped up, but we just ran out of steam. You don’t really know anything about these teams and they were just on another level.”
As they say, all good things come to an end. In the College World Series, the Bears unfortunately went two-and-out, but that didn’t put a damper on the miraculous run.
“We made our mark. We felt like we were the foundation and a lot of that core was going to remain.”
Cumbo was named Axcess Baseball’s College Player of the Year after hitting .437 with 7 HRs, 44 RBIs and 1.175 OPS.
2020
The COVID-19 pandemic wiped out the season in March of 2020, and very few teams dealt a bigger blow from it than NY Tech. They had brought in a monster recruiting class and they were once again looking like the beast of the region.
Not only did the pandemic end that but the final blow was delivered on August 20.
“I was in the Northwoods League in the dugout and I saw the tweet from the school that the athletic department was ceasing operations. Nobody knew about it. We had a team group chat and everyone was just like WHAT! Move in day was just around the corner too and everyone was paid.”
Cumbo noted that he went into a panic mode as he tried to find a new home. He called his buddy, Alex Passerella, who was on NY Tech the year before and transferred to Tampa. He got him in touch with the head coach. As luck would have it, they had a player that was on full scholarship quit the team right before the semester. Just like that a scholarship opened up for Cumbo.
The next day, he went to Tampa. With nowhere to live and no classes booked.
U Tampa
Thank you. @UT_Baseball https://t.co/wRGg1XZJcf
— EJ Cumbo (@CumboEj) June 14, 2024
Not many players from the northeast wind up playing at a powerhouse program like Cumbo but he was not like most players.
In his first year, he got back to the College World Series. Additionally, he got the year back because they only played 19 regular season games. He batted .388 with a 1.097 OPS. Following the season, he played his summer ball in Alaska. He noted that was the closest he ever got to being drafted, as he had heard from the Red Sox in the days leading up to the draft.
Surprisingly, it wound up being his last time playing summer ball during college due to various circumstances.
In 2022, he batted .340 with a .914 OPS and an identical 7 HRs and 44 RBIs just as he had done in 2019. Due to a torn pec, he did not play summer ball.
In 2023, he had an even better season. He batted .416 with 63 RBIs over 52 games. He was named First Team All-American – which he followed up the next year as well. In that season he had an OPS of 1.194 and once again went back to the College World Series.
This time, he reached the pinnacle.
They won the College World Series over Angelo State in the finals, going 52-8 on the season. Cumbo not only achieved the ultimate team goal, but set the Division-II hits record by finishing with exactly 400.
For his career, he batted .392 with 206 RBIs over 181 games at Tampa. Simply put, one of the best collegiate careers by a Long Island native.
Pro Ball
We’ve signed and activated OF EJ Cumbo to the roster after his acquisition in a trade with Long Island for a PTBN.
Cumbo is a multi-time All-American in college, the Division II hits king and a national champ in 2024 with @UTampaBaseball. Had a great year with Lexington (ATLL) in 2025.
📖: https://t.co/wTw7mO4Dsd
#GoWild— Washington Wild Things (@WashWildThings) May 29, 2026
“I had just won the championship. I felt like I accomplished everything that I wanted to. But I was hitting in the cage, and I said ‘I still feel good’. I had talked to some teams in the Atlantic League but their concern was a guy going right from college to their league.”
At previously mentioned, Cumbo’s 5’5 height made it exceptionally hard for him to get drafted. With the draft decreasing from 40 rounds to 20, it made it even more difficult. Despite that, he still got an opportunity to play ball with the Lexington Legends of the Atlantic League in the second half of the 2024 season.
Injuries, which had been a bugaboo for him in college, reared their head again. He broke the hamate bone in his hand. He played through it and still went 5-for-12 somehow. He told himself that he wasn’t going to go out like that and came back for 2025.
In the second game of the season, he got a concussion and got traded to the Ducks. Unfortunately, the Ducks brought in 3 other outfielders and he never got his chance. He was sent to the Washington Wildthings. He wound up playing around 20 games this season, and is considering coming back for another year.
The Next Chapter
Cumbo has stayed busy. He gives hitting lessons at Team Francisco, he is now running Showtime Select Florida and helping out with their new venture into Louisiana. He is the Director of Hitting for the Showtime organization. Additionally, he is involved with player development, metric tracking and recruiting for players on Long Island.
The Cumbo family is baseball through-and-through. If you have been paying attention to baseball on Long Island at any point in the last decade you have likely seen one of them on a field. And if it was E.J., you likely saw him go 3-for-4.