The Trusted Home of Amateur Baseball on Long Island – From Travel through College

search icon

News

Anthony Alberti’s Journey From Baseball Manager to College Player Is About More Than the Game

By Kevin Wigand

For nearly three years Anthony Alberti supported his Newfield High School baseball teammates from the dugout. He celebrated their victories, encouraged them through difficult moments and embraced his role even while waiting for an opportunity to take the field himself. 

When that opportunity finally arrived, the excitement extended well beyond the players in the dugout. 

Alberti’s journey from high school student manager to college baseball player has been built on patience, persistence and a willingness to put his teammates first. Along the way, the 21-year-old Alberti has earned the respect of coaches, mentors and teammates who say his impact has never depended on how much playing time he received. 

“I always believed that a winner was a loser who decided to keep trying,” Alberti, of Selden, said. 

His story began in March 2021 when former Newfield varsity head coach Eric Joyner first learned about him through a colleague during the COVID-19 pandemic. With students attending socially distanced physical education classes a colleague mentioned that Anthony played baseball during the summer on his father’s travel team.

After getting to know Alberti and his father Joe, Joyner brought Anthony aboard as a varsity student manager. 

Just three months later Alberti was in the middle of the celebration as Newfield won the first county championship in school history followed by its first Long Island championship. 

“Anthony was firmly woven into the fabric of who we were as a baseball brotherhood,” Joyner said. 

Joyner remembered Alberti bringing an unmatched passion for baseball, knowledge of the game and positive energy to the team. He also recalled that Alberti hated losing more than he liked winning, a mentality that resonated with his teammates. 

As Alberti entered his senior season in 2023, he remained a constant presence at practices and games. He got opportunities to throw bullpens and continued asking questions about how he could improve but he had yet to appear in a varsity game as a player. 

That changed against Ward Melville, when Alberti finally got his chance to pitch in the top of the sixth inning. Alumni gathered along the bullpen fence, and his teammates were buzzing with excitement. 

For Joyner, watching the moment unfold was unforgettable. After nearly three years of supporting the team, Alberti was finally wearing the uniform as a varsity player. 

The opportunity was brief, but the support surrounding him made it memorable.

Joyner knew Alberti’s baseball journey was far from over. He reached out to his longtime coaching acquaintance Pete Blumenauer at Suffolk County Community College, where he believed Alberti could continue contributing. 

“I told him if he had a need for a student manager/player, I have the perfect guy for you!” Joyner recalled. 

Alberti joined Suffolk as a manager in the spring of 2024. Initially, he primarily attended home games, but he quickly became a fixture in the dugout. 

Suffolk’s coach described him as a huge “vibes guy,” always supporting his teammates. Eventually Alberti began traveling with the team for away games and became one of the group. 

Brian Schlesinger, a mentor who met Alberti approximately six years ago, recognized that same quality. 

“I was so impressed by him because I was able to see how badly he wanted to take the field with his teammates,” Schlesinger said. “This kid never complained or was jealous of any player. He showed up every day and did nothing but support the group.” 

When Alberti returned to Suffolk the following fall, he wanted to become more than a manager. His coach told him that if he worked hard in practice and demonstrated improvement, he would have an opportunity to play. 

Alberti responded by showing up every day, competing in intersquad practices and conditioning, and continuing to improve.

In the spring, he received his first college playing opportunity as a pinch hitter against Monroe New Rochelle. He struck out, but it marked his first appearance in a college baseball game. 

Alberti’s first college pitching opportunity came against Borough of Manhattan Community College (BMCC). The nerves were real. He remembered shaking in the bullpen, his heart beating out of his chest. He kept reminding himself to throw strikes and give himself a chance. 

“If you get hit, you get hit. It happens. But just go out there and give yourself a chance,” he recalled telling himself. 

As Alberti warmed up during the game, excitement began building in the Suffolk dugout. His teammates knew what the opportunity meant to him, and they made sure he felt their support. 

“The bench was electric when he ran out to the mound,” Suffolk’s coach said. “It was one of the loudest benches I can remember, everyone on the fence screaming in support of Anthony.” 

Alberti recorded a scoreless inning, getting two outs on two pitches before striking out the final hitter for his first collegiate strikeout. 

“Guys from the bench ran out to greet him like he won the national championship,” the coach recalled. 

Suffolk went on to win the Region 15 championship that season, but for the coach, Alberti’s appearance remained one of the moments that stood out most. 

His father, Joe, recognized how remarkable the transformation had been. 

“The fact that he played as much as he did for Suffolk and won a game and played as much as he did is just off the charts from where he was 10 years ago,” his father said.

Alberti continued contributing the following season, recording his first college hit against BMCC, another milestone celebrated by his teammates, and pitching in multiple games. Against Bronx Community College, he also retired the leading hitter in the country, who had been producing hits throughout the series. 

His contributions extended beyond the field. At Suffolk, Alberti created social media interviews with teammates, giving them opportunities to share their personalities and opinions. He wanted them to feel heard and recognized. 

That instinct to support others has followed him to St. Joseph’s University, where he joined the baseball program during the fall semester. 

His new coach, Tom Caputo, said the transition was seamless. 

“His addition halfway through the fall was completely seamless. It’s like he’s been here for years,” Caputo said. “Anthony has a unique ability to learn and adapt to new environments with a quickness and ease that most adults lack.” 

Caputo praised Alberti’s contagious energy and wit, adding that he had already become an asset to the team. 

“I told him on his second day here that by the end of his tenure at St. Joseph’s he’ll be a rock star everywhere on campus,” Caputo said. 

For Alberti’s mother, the journey has been rewarding because her son’s love for baseball was never forced. “Anthony was a kid that was just allowed to cultivate his love for baseball naturally, it was never forced on him,” she said. 

She recalled that he was sometimes behind other players in ability, but the family trusted his coaches and encouraged him to keep improving. 

“We believed everything would play out the way it should, and it did,” she said. Schlesinger hopes younger players recognize what Alberti’s example represents. 

“He is exactly what every single coach wants every player to be like,” Schlesinger said. “I cannot think of anyone who deserves it more.” 

For Alberti, the journey is still unfolding. Whether he is managing, playing or finding another way to help his teammates, he has learned that being part of a team does not always require being in the spotlight. 

After spending years cheering for others from the dugout, he finally got to experience what it felt like when that same dugout erupted in celebration for him.

 

Kevin Wigand is a reporter with The SBU Media Group, part of Stony Brook University’s School of Communication and Journalism’s Working Newsroom program for students and local media.