Editor’s Note: This is the 19th installment of the Up Next Series in which we highlight the top underclassmen on Long Island. Previously, we featured Jack Mulligan, Alex Pagano, Quincy Gibbs, Michael Cotto, Charlie Edwards, Evan Picciano, Nick Lawrence, Robbie Mascia, Jacob Abran, Tyler Camastro, Jason Davis, Michael Garcia ,Vincent Bourne, Nate Lewis, Jack Yonkman, Andrew McQuade , Dean Geiger. and Matthew Passantino. Special thanks to Ken Kortright State Farm Agency for sponsoring this year’s series.
LHP Conor Dietz (Shoreham-Wading River 2028) pic.twitter.com/sOiypYyUgD
— Axcess Baseball LI (@axcessbaseball) March 2, 2026
It is not often that a playoff team relies on an underclassmen to anchor the rotation. That is likely to be the case this year for perennial powerhouse Shoreham-Wading River, who will be leaning on sophomore southpaw Conor Dietz to pitch like an ace in 2026.
Fortunately, it won’t be a new task for the hard-throwing 10th grader.
As a freshman, he compiled a 1.70 ERA over 39 innings with 41 Ks against 17 walks. He notched a very impressive 1.05 WHIP on the season and was named All-League for his accomplishments. Additionally, he handled the bat well; batting .310 with a team-leading 10 RBIs.
Dietz, a member of the Body Armor Titans, pitched extremely well in the summer as well. He was named the MVP of the PG East Coast Elite Championship, as well as All-Tournament team in the PG New England Elite Championship and PG Northeast World Series.
This winter, he has continued to improve as his fastball velocity has increased to 88.5 MPH and has been ranked as the No. 1 southpaw pitcher in the 2028 class in NY.
His pitching coach, Ryan Horstman, had the following to say:
“I’ve had the pleasure of working with Conor over the past three years. During that time, he has developed from sitting 75 MPH to topping out at 88.5 MPH on his fastball. His fastball and changeup both generate elite levels of arm side run, allowing him to consistently miss bats at a high rate. Conor is extremely projectable with a very high ceiling. Beyond his physical tools and on-field performance, his work ethic and confidence truly set him apart. He is committed to his development and embraces the process every single day. Do not be surprised if, by this fall, he earns a scholarship from a power five program.”
He spoke with Axcess Baseball and here’s what he had to say…
Was baseball always your No. 1 sport? Do you play any other sports?
Yes, it has always been my main sport but I also play golf.
Who are some people that have had a positive impact on your career?
Family and all my coaches. Also, all of my competition.
What was it like playing varsity as a freshman? How long would you say it was until you were totally comfortable?
I made varsity as an eighth grader but I was comfortable the second I was on the mound in 9th grade after the experience I had gained giving pitched a couple of innings for varsity during my eighth grade year.
What did you want to work on this offseason?
Putting on weight and getting stronger.
Goals for 2026?
Hit 90 MPH
What has been your most thrilling moment on a baseball field?
Hitting a game-tying HR in Cooperstown in a late night game.
Any family members played college sports?
Yes, my 2 cousins; Bobby and Travis Honeyman. Bobby was drafted out of Stony Brook University by the Seattle Mariners and Travis is currently playing with the St. Louis Cardinals.
How have you enjoyed your time with the Titans?
Yes so far I love it. Great coaches, players and overall experience.
Do you work with any private instructors?
Yes, Ryan Horstman is my pitching coach and also my trainer.
Best baseball trip you’ve been on?
As a young player – All Star Village in Cooperstown. It was a great experience and I hit 13 home runs. I got to go twice.
Favorite restaurant on Long Island?
Blackstone Steak House
Favorite musical artist?
Rihanna or DaBaby
Favorite app on your phone?
Probably TikTok, it is very easy to learn new things and being able to visually see how.
Favorite TV Show or movie?
Show: Henry Danger
Movie: White Chicks
Favorite vacation spot?
Costa Rica
Dream Car?
BMW X5 Competition, all blacked out
