Special thanks to Metamorphosis Landscape Design for sponsoring this year’s series
by Ryan Manno
The Pierson Whalers enter the season embracing a new chapter, shaped by a standard rooted in work ethic. After graduating six seniors, this year’s group looks different on paper, but Head Coach Bob Manning believes the foundation is stronger than ever. The focus is simple: compete every day, outwork opponents, and let that mindset define the season.
Last year ended in the Suffolk County playoffs against Babylon, a team Coach Manning described as a “buzz saw”. Babylon proved to be the better and deeper team, but the ending did not erase what Pierson accomplished. As the smallest Class B school, the Whalers battled through an extremely competitive league and won six straight games to earn their spot in counties. That stretch showcased the team’s toughness and belief, traits that now carry into this season with higher expectations and a clearer identity.
Replacing the graduated seniors will be one of the biggest challenges. Andy Wayne (Mitchell), Braeden Mott (P27), Paul Roesel (Sage), Lucas Lulo, and Max Krotman leave behind experience that cannot be replicated overnight. Coach Manning emphasized that the innings, leadership, and overall composure they provided will be difficult to replace, making development essential from day one.
Congrats to our guy Braeden Mott, huge summer ahead for this guy!!! pic.twitter.com/3s7HFzJJUM
— PAL Blue Line Rangers (@BlueLineRangers) May 30, 2025
The coaching staff also experienced change, as Tyler LaBorne moved on after six years with the program. Stepping into a key role is Matt Heffernan, a Fredonia and Mattituck alum, who has already become a huge asset to the development pipeline of the team. His presence has added energy, structure, and insight, helping guide a roster that blends experienced veterans with younger players.
Leadership starts with the senior class, particularly behind the plate. Jeffrey Gregor, a four-year varsity player, is the backbone of the team defensively and emotionally. He runs the defense, manages the pitching staff and sets the daily standard.
All-League senior Spencer Cavaniola impacts the game in every phase. Standing 6 foot 2, he struck out 42 batters in 31 innings last season and serves as the starting shortstop when not on the mound. Offensively, he hit .320 with 23 hits and 10 stolen bases, making him one of the most dynamic and reliable players on the roster.
Spencer Cavaniola (Pierson 2026) with a strikeout to strand the bases loaded pic.twitter.com/8gRVeEstDd
— Axcess Baseball LI (@axcessbaseball) June 23, 2024
Junior Brian Schroeder is the definition of versatile. Last season he played every position except catcher and first base, earning increased opportunities on the mound along the way. Coach Manning views him as a superior athlete with the right attitude, someone willing to do whatever the team needs.
Senior Finlay Panton brings upside to the pitching staff after throwing 15.2 innings last year. He spent the offseason focused on refining his pitching and strengthening his legs, and his nasty mix of pitches gives him the potential to be a major factor.
Senior Evan Mitchell looks to bounce back after injuries limited him last season. With quick hands and power to all fields, he is expected to contribute at the corners, in the outfield, and on the mound, giving the Whalers valuable flexibility.
Michael Schaefer anchors first base and is coming off a strong offseason. Coach Manning expects him to continue that momentum by providing the squad with tight defense and emerging as a vocal presence within the lineup.
Alongside the veterans, a younger group is ready to make its mark. Juniors Nick D’Angelo, Martin Milazzo, and Kai Greene lead a crop of hungry players who are eager to prove they belong at the varsity level.
For Pierson to succeed, the formula is clear. The Whalers must utilize timely hitting with minimal mistakes. Pitching and postseason experience remain strengths, while filling out the rotation and replacing senior leadership remain the primary challenges.
Coach Manning believes this team is something special across the roster. With a mix of proven leaders and motivated newcomers, the Whalers enter the season united by a standard that defines everything they do.
